Choosing between the Remington 1187 and the 1100 can be a tough decision for shotgunners. Both are legendary names in the field, boasting decades of reliable performance. However, understanding their key differences is crucial to selecting the right gun for your specific needs and shooting style. This in-depth comparison will delve into the features, performance, and overall value of each model to help you make an informed choice.
Design and Action: A Tale of Two Systems
The most significant difference lies in their operating systems. The Remington 1100 utilizes a gas-operated action, while the 1187 employs a self-regulating inertia system. Let's break down what that means:
Remington 1100 (Gas-Operated):
- Mechanism: Uses gas pressure from the fired shell to cycle the action. A portion of the expanding gases is diverted to push a piston, which in turn cycles the bolt.
- Reliability: Generally reliable, but can be sensitive to variations in ammunition type and cleanliness. Proper cleaning and lubrication are essential for optimal performance.
- Recoil: The gas system helps mitigate recoil, making it a relatively comfortable shooter, particularly for higher-powered loads.
Remington 1187 (Inertia-Driven):
- Mechanism: A simpler design relies on the recoil energy of the fired shell to cycle the action. The bolt remains locked until the force of recoil overcomes the inertia of the bolt, allowing it to cycle.
- Reliability: Known for its robust reliability, often cited as being less sensitive to variations in ammunition or dirt buildup than gas-operated systems. Still, regular cleaning is recommended.
- Recoil: While less recoil-reducing than the gas-operated 1100, the 1187's recoil is manageable and many shooters find it perfectly acceptable.
Features and Handling: Subtle Differences, Significant Impact
While both shotguns share a similar profile, several subtle differences influence handling and overall shooting experience:
- Weight and Balance: The 1100 generally feels slightly lighter and more nimble, particularly in the field. The 1187, while not overly heavy, can feel slightly more substantial. The balance point varies slightly between models and barrel lengths, so handling should be tested personally if possible.
- Ease of Maintenance: The 1187's simpler inertia system often translates to easier cleaning and maintenance compared to the 1100's gas system, which necessitates a more thorough cleaning process.
- Durability: Both are known for their rugged construction, but anecdotal evidence suggests the 1187 might offer slightly increased durability due to fewer moving parts in its action.
Performance and Applications: Where Each Excels
Both shotguns excel in a variety of applications, from hunting waterfowl and upland birds to clayshooting. However, slight nuances exist:
- Waterfowl Hunting: The gas-operated 1100 can handle heavier loads with greater ease, making it a popular choice for waterfowl hunting, particularly when using steel shot.
- Upland Bird Hunting: The lighter weight and potentially quicker cycling of the 1100 can be beneficial for fast-paced upland bird hunting. The 1187, however, handles lighter loads reliably and is a suitable choice as well.
- Clay Shooting: Both shotguns are capable of competitive clay shooting performance. The choice often comes down to personal preference regarding recoil, handling, and cycling speed.
The Verdict: Choosing Your Champion
Ultimately, the "better" shotgun depends entirely on individual needs and preferences.
Choose the Remington 1100 if:
- You prioritize a softer-shooting experience, especially with heavier loads.
- You are comfortable with more involved cleaning and maintenance procedures.
- You often shoot in challenging conditions where a reliable gas-operated system might offer an advantage.
Choose the Remington 1187 if:
- Simplicity and reliability are paramount.
- Easier maintenance is a priority.
- You prefer a potentially more durable design with fewer moving parts.
Before making your decision, it is highly recommended to handle both shotguns, if possible. Shoulder them, cycle the action, and assess which feels more comfortable and intuitive for your shooting style. Consider your intended applications and prioritize the features that best align with your needs. This thoughtful approach will help you choose the Remington shotgun that will serve you well for years to come.
